Real at source: apps and tools that keep things real from the start
The strongest proof that something is real is made at the moment it is captured. Checking it later is harder and less certain. This page collects apps and tools that keep things real at source, and the design choices behind them. If you are building one, we would like to hear from you.
Why the source matters most
Spotting a fake afterwards is hard. AI detectors often disagree with each other, and they get less reliable as image generators improve. A missing label proves nothing either way.
At the source, the facts are still there: the time, the place, the device and the person holding it. An app that records them, or never lets an invented image in, gives everyone after it something solid to check. Detection is still needed for everything else. The more that is real at source, the less has to be guessed later.
None of these tools can prove that everything in them is real. Each one closes some doors and leaves others open. The useful ones say which.
Six design choices that help
1. Capture instead of upload
If a photo can only be taken inside the app, at that moment, nothing can arrive from a camera roll, a download or an image generator.
2. Leave the original alone
Filters that reshape faces or swap skies change what happened. Keep the original exactly as it was taken, even when it is blurred or someone blinked.
3. Make AI edits a separate, labelled copy
If people want a playful AI version, make it a new copy with a visible label in the image itself, so the label travels with every copy. The original stays untouched.
4. Keep a record of when and where
Store the time, the place and a fingerprint of each file. Content Credentials and independent timestamps let people outside the app check that record later.
5. Show people where it came from
Tell viewers how a picture was made: taken live, edited, or generated. A record nobody can see does little for trust.
6. Say what you cannot prove
Every method has gaps. Someone can still photograph a screen. Be open about the limits so people do not trust a result more than it deserves.
Projects
Each project is described by what it does and what it cannot prove. Being listed is free and is not an endorsement.
here.photo
A camera for real moments. Photos are taken live in the browser, where you are, and can join a shared wall for that place. Places that host a wall pay for it, and there is an optional membership.
Places cannot pay to be listed higher or shown anywhere else. They are listed by distance or recent photos, and a place's own news only shows when you open its page. Members' photos get priority in the shared reel.
- Capture only. Photos cannot be uploaded from a camera roll or another app.
- No reshaping filters. The photo stays as it was taken.
- AI copies are labelled. On special occasions a playful AI version of a photo may be offered. It is always a separate copy with "AI-EDITED" stamped into the image, and the original is unchanged.
- Timestamped. A fingerprint of each photo is timestamped every night by two independent services, so the photographer can later show the photo existed by then, and check a copy found elsewhere against the original.
What it cannot prove: that what was in front of the camera was real. Someone could photograph a screen. Photos do not carry Content Credentials, and only the photographer can run the copy check.
Disclosure: here.photo is made by RELTY's founder. It is listed on the same terms as any other project. Read its own account on here.photo/philosophy.
This list is just starting. We will add projects as people tell us about them, and describe each one the same way.
Add your project
We are looking for apps, tools, cameras, plug-ins and open-source libraries that keep people's media real at source. Small projects and early ones are welcome, as long as people can use them today.
To be listed, a project should:
- use at least one of the design choices above
- say clearly what it can and cannot prove
- say who runs it and how it is paid for
- not claim to detect every fake
Email volunteer@relty.org with the name, a link, and a few lines on which choices it uses and where its limits are. Commercial projects are welcome.
- Nobody can pay to be listed, or to be described more favourably.
- A listing is not a partnership or an endorsement.
- We describe the limits as well as the strengths, and you can correct anything we get wrong.
- If a project changes and no longer fits, we will remove it.
We only use what you send to consider and describe your project. Ask us to delete it at any time.
