How to spot fake reviews and listings made with AI
Reviews, photos and profiles help us decide what to buy, where to stay and who to trust. AI makes all three cheap to fake. This guide covers product reviews, holiday rentals and dating profiles, and the checks that work for each.
1. Why reading is not enough
A chatbot can write a hundred different glowing reviews in a minute. An image generator can make a holiday flat that does not exist. The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) says you often cannot reliably tell a real review from a fake one just by reading it.
AI photos are hard to spot too. In research by Airbnb and Get Safe Online, UK adults were shown four AI-generated property images. More than a third (34%) thought they were real, and more than a quarter (27%) were not sure.
So do not try to judge the words or the pictures alone. Check the pattern around them: who posted, when, where else they appear, and what you are being asked to do. Our guide on how to tell if text was written by AI explains why detector scores will not settle it either.
Fake reviews are not always positive. The FTC notes that some businesses post fake negative reviews to harm a competitor.
2. Check product reviews
Consumer group Which? and the FTC both suggest these checks.
- Read beyond the stars. Read the four, three and two-star reviews. They are often more balanced.
- Look at the dates. Many reviews posted in a short space of time is a warning sign. Sort by most recent, because the default order can be gamed.
- Look at the reviewer. Open their profile and see what else they have reviewed. An account that exists only to post one review may be fake. So may one that has praised lots of unrelated products.
- Check the review is about this product. Which? warns of "review merging", where reviews for a different product appear under the same listing.
- Look for "verified purchase". It means the marketplace can confirm the item was bought on its site.
- Watch for incentives. Mentions of gift cards, refunds or free products in return for a review deserve caution. Some sites label these reviews.
- Go elsewhere. Read independent expert reviews from well-known outlets, not only the reviews on the shop's own page.
Many near-identical reviews with the same structure and phrases are worth a closer look. On their own, though, they do not prove anything.
3. Check the shop or offer
Fake reviews often sit on fake shops, or under adverts for offers that do not exist.
- If you do not know the brand, check that it has a proper website with working contact details. Which? recommends this before you buy.
- If an advert says it comes from a big brand, go to the brand's own website or official social media page and look for the offer there. Full Fact gives this advice for fake giveaways. Our guide on checking if a social media account is real shows how to find the official page.
- Be careful with "only this week" deadlines and prizes in return for filling in a form.
- A video of a happy customer or a spokesperson can be made with AI. Our deepfake guide covers what to look for.
4. Holiday rentals
Fake rental listings take your deposit for a place that does not exist, or that is not theirs to let.
- Search the photos. Run a reverse image search on the listing photos. If the same rooms appear under another name, in another town or on an estate agent's site, walk away. If they appear nowhere, they may be new, or they may be made with AI.
- Check the address. Look the address up on an online map and street view. Does the building match the photos?
- Stay on the platform. Airbnb and Get Safe Online advise booking, paying and messaging through a trusted platform. Airbnb says asking you to move a booking or messages off Airbnb before you book is against its policy. If you pay outside Airbnb, you lose its AirCover protection.
- Do not pay by bank transfer. Airbnb and Get Safe Online advise against paying for a holiday or accommodation by direct bank transfer. Airbnb says a request to pay by wire or bank transfer may be a sign of a fraudulent reservation.
- Be wary of bargains. Unusually cheap deals, high deposits and pressure to decide quickly are all warning signs.
- Do not follow links in messages. Go to the app or website yourself.
5. Dating profiles
Fake profiles on dating apps and social media are the start of many romance scams. The FTC describes a common pattern.
- The person says they live or work far away, for example overseas, on an oil rig or in the military, so you never meet.
- Sooner or later they ask for money, for medical bills, travel, visas or fees, or suggest you invest in cryptocurrency.
- They want payment by wire transfer, gift card, money transfer app or cryptocurrency, which are hard to get back.
The FTC advises a reverse image search of the profile picture to see whether it appears under other names. A face with no earlier copies at all is not proof either way. It could be a private photo, or an AI-made face. You can also search the person's claimed job with the word "scammer" to see whether others have reported the same story.
The FTC's rule of thumb: never send money or gifts to someone you have not met in person. If you are unsure, stop replying and talk to someone you trust.
6. Report it
- Report fake reviews, listings and profiles to the site or app where you found them.
- If you lost money or shared card details, contact your bank straight away.
- In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, report fraud to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040. It replaced Action Fraud in December 2025.
- In Spain, INCIBE's free helpline 017 gives cybersecurity advice every day from 8:00 to 23:00.
Fake reviews are also against the law in more places now. In the UK, fake reviews were banned on 6 April 2025, and businesses and platforms must take steps to prevent and remove them. In the US, the FTC announced a rule in August 2024 banning fake reviews, and it names AI-generated fake reviews as a target.
7. Decide what you can say
- Verified. The seller, host or person checks out through independent routes, such as an official website, a confirmed address or a video call you set up.
- AI-generated or altered. The photos are stolen or made with AI, the reviews are copied or invented, or the advert uses an AI video.
- Misleading context. The reviews are real but belong to a different product, or the photos show a different property.
- Unverified. You could not confirm who is behind it. Do not pay until you can.
With money involved, you do not need proof that something is fake. If you cannot check it, do not pay.
In the news
Recent reports from RELTY's AI news that show why this check matters.
- 12 November 2026 · The Verge
AI chatbots recommended fake retail websites in a study
The Verge reports a study by IP protection firm Podqi. It says ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity sent shoppers to imposter and risky sites when asked shopping questions. A shop suggested by a chatbot still needs checking.
- 11 November 2026 · Full Fact
AI-made Facebook ad promised a fake Tesco grocery giveaway
Full Fact found a SynthID watermark in the ad's video, and Tesco said the offer was not genuine. There was no such deal on Tesco's own website or Facebook page. Checking the brand's official pages settled it.
Sources
The pages this guide relies on, checked on 15 November 2026.
- How to evaluate online reviews. US Federal Trade Commission.
- How to spot a fake review. Which?
- Airbnb and Get Safe Online raise awareness of holiday scams this Easter. Airbnb, February 2025.
- Paying and communicating through Airbnb. Airbnb Help Centre.
- What to know about romance scams. US Federal Trade Commission.
- Facebook ad offers fake Tesco grocery package giveaway. Full Fact, November 2026.
- Fake reviews and sneaky hidden fees banned once and for all. UK Government, April 2025.
- Federal Trade Commission announces final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials. US Federal Trade Commission, August 2024.
- New Report Fraud service launched to tackle cyber crime and fraud. Gwent Police and Crime Commissioner, December 2025.
- Tu Ayuda en Ciberseguridad (017). INCIBE.
Why AI detectors disagree, and how to read their results
How to spot a voice-clone scam call
How to tell if text was written by AI
How to reverse image search a photo
Browse the RELTY directory of tools
Links to other organisations are for reference only. RELTY has no partnership with, or endorsement from, any of them.
